Skip to main content

A Short Guide to Citation of Authorities

© Anshuman Sahoo 2018. 
Free for mass distribution as long as the source is mentioned.

The quality and quantity of authorities cited to support a statement is one of the determining aspects that defines the reliability as well as the acceptability of a statement. Be it a memorial, a research paper, or an assignment article towards a law school grading, the importance of citing authorities remains undisputed.
Given the importance of citing authorities, this also remains a fact that citation of authorities has always been a confusing and misleading thing. Deciding where to cite, why to cite, and which ones to cite are often difficult decisions a law student has to face. With an endeavour to put an end to this, the current article deals with two basic questions: why do we cite authorities, and which ones are worth citing.
First, why do we cite authorities?
We cite authorities to support our claim about something, as authorities have the ability to strengthen or weaken a claim. Strictly analysed, authorities can be cited in any of the following three cases:
1.      Authority for assertion: While making a claim or statement, there’s nothing worse than making a baseless assertion. However, made the right way, assertions can be a powerful tool for your argument. Citing authorities is the magic tool you can use to make assertions the right way.
Whenever you make an assertion, always try to cite authorities. This will strengthen your claim, and your argument.
2.      Attribution to source: Plagiarism is a crime you would not want to commit while writing a research paper; but citing authorities can turn your plagiarism into well-researched support-pillars.
Cite sources whenever you quote, or refer (copy) something as it is. It’ll save you from the allegation of plagiarism while strengthening your research.
3.      Further reading: While writing a paper, there’ll be places where you would want to keep elaborating and writing on a single issue because it’s really interesting and deep. As tempting as this may sound, it must be avoided as it does injustice to other issues, thereby making your paper look handicapped.
This is where citations come to your rescue. Cite further reading and ‘See also’ materials to make sure that the interested reader can explore more if he wants without disturbing the flow of the paper.



Second, which ones to cite?
It is not uncommon to encounter dozens of materials on a single issue while you are on the hunt for authorities. The question there is, which are the ones worth citing?
While there are several ways to evaluate resources, I personally prefer the CARS checklist: it’s short, plus easy to remember!
The CARS checklist stands for four points that must be checked while evaluating a resource. The better the resource/authority scores on these four points, the better the authority. The CARS checklist expands as follows:
C: Credibility
A: Accuracy
R: Reasonableness
S: Support
That translates to the following statement:
‘The better credibility, accuracy, reasonableness, and support a resource possesses, the better it is as an authority.’
This is all.

As for ‘how to cite’, most CFPs (Call for Papers) will rule down the citation system to be followed while writing the paper. If not mentioned, keep in mind that there are two basic citation systems for writing papers related to law and legal studies: OSCOLA and Bluebook. My earlier post on citing using Bluebook may help you here.

Popular posts

Citing Legal Materials Using Bluebook - A Short Guide

©Anshuman Sahoo 2017. 
Free for mass distribution till the source is properly mentioned.



So, you collected the relevant materials for your research, went through them carefully, and evaluated the available materials. Now, what remains is to carefully dot down your arguments in your own words while supporting those arguments and ideas by citing relevant materials in the footnotes. It is necessary to cite relevant legal material that you have referred to because it reflects your research and in-depth study that you have undertaken to write that paper. Apart from that, while quoting the work of someone else, citation is necessary to avoid possible allegations of plagiarism. However, while citing the materials in the footnotes section, you cannot cite them as per your wish. For example, while citing page no. 99 of ‘The Start-up of You’ book written by Reid Hoffman, you cannot cite it as ‘page 99, The Start-up of You, Reid Hoffmann’ just because that seems convenient. There is a standard metho…

On Indianness: #Throwback to a long-forgotten tradition

“आनोभद्राःक्रतवोयन्तुविश्वतः” – Rig Veda(Let noble thoughts come to me from all directions.)
(In honour of the 5000-year old culture that taught me to de-contextualise and de-personalise every piece of wisdom.)The India that we get to see today came into being only in 1947, and later.
Prior to that, the whole landmass that we refer to as India was never a part of a single empire, never had a uniform governance, evidently had a high-degree of socio-cultural as well as geographical diversity, and seemingly had no single feature which can be found to be common across the subcontinent. And yet, not only the outer world recognised this whole landmass as one, but the people inside somewhere had this feeling that they’re one – they belong to one!
Interesting, but how?
The whole subcontinent, throughout its history, no matter how diverse it was in its socio-cultural and political affairs, has always had a common essence – a common signature trait that was rare in other contemporary civilisations…

A journey called Law School: Few words for the newcomers

Law school has its own ways to teach us the needed, regardless of our consent or interest thereto! However, gradually, through the ups and downs of our journey, it seems that while there are some things that we can change, there also exist some things that need to be accepted. I have had my fair share of ‘law school experiences’ to enable me to write this piece. However, I cannot guarantee that you’ll be having the same experiences through your journey. Therefore, inapplicability regretted. So, shall we start? 1. You’ll be facing tough competitions. Yes, cutthroat competition. You’ll compete with unfaithful friends and sincere enemies. Be prepared to be betrayed, used, and knocked out. However, don’t let this affect you. Everyone you meet in Law School isn’t your competition, but a potential ally. Learn to build meaningful relationships. Remember, legends don’t compete, they collaborate! 2. You’ll be having not-so-competent teachers teach you. We all face it. And not just here, it’s …